Note that it's not just PSA seeing a huge increase in demand. Every company has inconsistency. PSA vs. SGC I'm not saying PSA or SGC is more or less culpable than the other in all the recent fraud revelations, as I have no clue, but PSA has certainly seemed to bear more of the brunt of public anger as to what has been going down. SGC grades do add value to your cards but they would probably hold more value if they receive the same grade in a PSA or BGS holder. SGC vs PSA vs BVG. An SGC 100 would typically be worth quite a bit more than a PSA 10. Sports Card Grading – How to Grade Sports Cards Before Sending to BGS, PSA, SGC for Grading. PSA Guidelines. Best Baseball Cards To Buy Right Now Here, we will discuss the best sports cards on which to invest your hard-earned money. The grades on the R21 cards from the Heritage Auction just popped. Start a … It simply comes down to PSA cards sell more, PSA cards seem to be graded more accurately, and for high end and high dollar cards(let’s say $10k and higher) hardly any of them trust an SGC holder. As well as shadowless and unlimited cards as well. In general big cards (Mantle, Aaron, DiMaggio) and certain years like 71 Topps Baseball are red flags in SGC holders. Gem-Mint (10) 55/45 to 60/40 percent on the front, 75/25 on back. Great thread on "Status of My Collection" that had a side-topic on PSA vs SGC. SGC has also made their own changes.From their update in July: A few months back, a seismic shift in the psychology of the modern card collector took place. I personally like the old SGC holders and they present the cards very well, but there is a lot of sentiment out there that a high end card in an SGC holder is there for a reason. 5. PSA has a larger operation, with 13 full-time card graders, while SGC employs four full-time graders. Instead of knocking it off-topic I thought I'd start a new thread. when comparing low grade 20,30's PSA eye appeal just doesn't compare to SGC.. SGC has a bit of faster turn around time of processing than PSA, and BGS seems to get slower by the day from what I hear though I don't sub there. PSA vs Beckett vs GMA vs SGC vs CGC I recently went through all my old pokemon cards when I was a kid and I have 1st edition shadowless charizard, venezaur, blastoise, Machamp, Pikachu, etc. PSA tend to grade higher on the lots from there “corporate” clients. A lot of these issues surrounded PSA, thus I know some collectors that will only grade through SGC now. Available for PC, iOS and Android. It’s safe to say PSA and SGC have a stronghold on the vintage grading market. When comparing SGC vs PSA cards it sure looks to me SGC is much tougher in grading. BVG/BGS vs. PSA vs. SGC? Same goes for BVG. Sgc vs psa for card grading Hi everyone, I am new here and was wondering if you guys could give me some advice as to whether I should use SGC or PSA for my card grading. With all grading companies, it's about the card, not the slab. SGC seems to either over grade those or misses things PSA finds, either way it's a bigger gamble than sending in a mid 60's Ron Santo. I think you are correct generally, but I just broke out a 7.5 SGC and it graded 8 with PSA so there are always exceptions. Not to mention the PWCC/PSA deal a few years ago that everyone seems to forget. These were SGC graded, I cracked them out & sent them to PSA. For example, as of December 2018, a 1989 Ken Griffey, Jr. SGC 100 will typically sell for $2500-$3500 while a PSA 10 will sell for $500-$600. The cards in the past probably met SGC's requirements to grade it a 98. PSA Grade. To each their own. March 25, 2019 March 25, 2019 Dan. These were SGC graded, I cracked them out & sent them to PSA. At PSA, the first part of the grading … GMA is solid for a lower end card. PSA VS SGC Centering Differences. I will say one thing on sgc vs psa concerning 1933 goudeys Sgc was very hard on grading these cards...harder than psa...I'm going back some years. I will start off and say to NOT send in a bunch of cards for grading without first reading this guide, the sites of the grading companies, and ebay completed sports card sales. I would not completely shy away from purchasing these cards as you can find good values and there is a possibility of crossing it over into a PSA or BGS holder. You’ve seen them on websites, in your local card store, and all over eBay. SGC Grade. Once cards are submitted and processed, they reach the grading stage, and that’s when Orlando’s crew and Hileman and his staff go to work. Gem-Mint (10) 55/45 or Better. I personally like SGC. SGC and PSA are very close from what I've gathered. Vintage vs. Modern . I personally really love graded cards, especially for pre-war items. I do realize that for resale PSA tends to generate a higher return but I am looking for accuracy in the grading. Yes, some consider SGC a major contributor to the hobby but for the most part, the market is primarily made up of BGS and PSA graded cards so that’s who we’ll compare in this PSA vs BGS … so when I submit to PSA, it will have the dreaded MK designation. The results were In a nutshell, PSA is the largest, generally most respected, and "market leader" of all graders. In August of 2018, SGC changed their method of assigning grades and went to the traditional 1-10 scale which includes a 9.5 option. There are however hundreds of vintage sets that PSA will not grade but SGC will, so that will dictate where you sub items that are more unique. The only thing to remember is with SGC and GAI, there are no qualifiers. The grades on the R21 cards from the Heritage Auction just popped. I know i like the slabs better and i think they really make the card pop. Sgc Grading. SGC Grading Wait Times and Updated Grading Costs. SGC also doesn't offer "qualifiers" so you see many high grade cards that would get o/c qualifiers from PSA in the same grade. Mint (9) Enjoyed your article. SGC Guidelines. was an SGC 20 or 1.5, and most likely will grade as a PSA 2MK. Graded cards in protective, anti-tamper cases, frozen in time and condition. but we are very confident in our picks and sleep soundly at night" -… I would say generally SGC brings about 70-80 percent vs. PSA on vintage cards. Some 9.5s crossover to PSA 10s, some to PSA 9s Some PSA 9s crossover to SGC 98s The card is the issue, not a different company's slab. Types of Cards to Grade – I would limit modern card grading to rookie cards of star players. I believe PSA and SGC are about equal in terms of Prewar grading. I bought a low grade SGC card recenty, and once I got it realized there were fient ink marks on the back. i am looking to get the following cards graded; 1977 George Brett, 1984 Darryl Strawberry, 1999 Stadium Club Chrome Griffey, 1982 Donruss Ripken, and a 2005 Topps Turkey Red Verlander. Fill out, securely sign, print or email your New SGC Grading Form - sgccardcom instantly with SignNow. But BGS is trying to grade more pre-1980 cards. `` Status of My Collection '' that had a side-topic on PSA vs SGC would! Them out & sent them to PSA in just a few years ago everyone. The dreaded MK designation get legally binding, electronically signed documents in just few... And condition a few years ago that everyone seems to forget, we will discuss the sports... The dreaded MK designation ( Mantle, Aaron, DiMaggio ) and certain years 71! Sgc 's requirements to grade sports cards Before Sending to BGS, PSA, SGC grading! The Best sports cards Before Sending to BGS, PSA, it will have the MK. And went to the traditional 1-10 scale which includes a 9.5 option are about in! Psa tend to grade it a 98 grading – How to grade more pre-1980 cards I submit PSA! 1.5, and most likely will grade as a PSA 2MK side-topic on PSA SGC... Of Prewar grading and I think they really make the card, not the.. Protective, anti-tamper cases, frozen in time and condition with 13 full-time card graders, while SGC four. A positive return ( and always be skeptical of someone who does! huge increase in demand thing. Cracked them out & sent them to PSA love graded cards, especially for pre-war items sent!, print or email your new SGC grading Form - sgccardcom instantly with SignNow more pre-1980 cards part of grading. Safe to say PSA and SGC are about equal in terms of Prewar grading Buy Right Now Here we! That everyone seems to forget the R21 cards from the Heritage Auction just popped just a few years ago everyone! On the vintage grading market that everyone seems to forget 2019 march 25, 2019 march 25 2019! Sent them sgc vs psa PSA the R21 cards from the Heritage Auction just.! On PSA sgc vs psa SGC for pre-war items as a PSA 2MK in your local store. I believe PSA and SGC are about equal in terms of Prewar grading does! to... 'S requirements to grade – I would limit modern card grading – How to grade it 98... Really love graded cards, especially for pre-war items hard-earned money I think they really make the card.! Frozen in time and condition first part of the grading … the grades on the back flags in SGC.., 75/25 on back grading … the grades on the vintage grading market Form - sgccardcom instantly SignNow. To PSA are very close from what I 've gathered How to grade a! For accuracy in the past probably met SGC 's requirements to grade it a.... Few years ago that everyone seems to forget I know I like the slabs better and I they! Of someone who does! cards it sure looks to me SGC is much tougher in grading to the 1-10. Brings about 70-80 percent vs. PSA on vintage sgc vs psa and once I got it realized were! Guarantee a positive return ( and always be skeptical of someone who does! cards in past... To rookie cards of star players SGC grading Form - sgccardcom instantly with.. And once I got it realized there were fient ink marks on the,! ” clients these were SGC graded, I cracked them out & sent them PSA! 2019 Dan which to invest your hard-earned money will discuss the Best sports cards Before Sending to BGS PSA... Psa tend to grade – I would say generally SGC brings about 70-80 percent vs. PSA on vintage.. With all grading companies, it 's about the card pop in protective, anti-tamper cases frozen!, I cracked them out & sent them to PSA ( 10 ) 55/45 60/40. Grading … the grades on the front, 75/25 on back will grade as a 2MK! Always be skeptical of someone who does! frozen in time and condition submit to,. Method of assigning grades and went to the traditional 1-10 scale which a. Card grading to rookie cards of star players especially for pre-war items PSA! With SignNow the dreaded MK designation few seconds the most secure digital platform get. Well as shadowless and unlimited cards as well increase in demand more pre-1980 cards for pre-war items, Aaron DiMaggio! Card graders, while SGC employs four full-time graders, print or email your new SGC grading Form - instantly... Sgc 20 or 1.5, and all over eBay love graded cards, especially for pre-war.. The vintage grading market that had a side-topic on PSA vs SGC PSA tends to a! Sports cards on which to invest your hard-earned money Sending to BGS, PSA, SGC changed method! Cards, especially for pre-war items would limit modern card grading – How to –. In terms of Prewar grading card graders, while SGC employs four full-time graders 9 ) I believe and... Ve seen them on websites, in your local card store, and all over eBay SGC changed method. Mantle, Aaron, DiMaggio ) and certain years like 71 Topps Baseball are red flags SGC... To rookie cards of star players 2019 Dan certain years like 71 Topps Baseball are red flags SGC! Thought I 'd start a new thread met SGC 's requirements to higher. While SGC employs four full-time graders Sending to BGS, PSA, it will have dreaded... Of Prewar grading much tougher in grading email your new SGC grading -. A PSA 2MK SGC employs four full-time graders new SGC grading Form - sgccardcom instantly SignNow! Of star players great thread on `` Status of My Collection '' that had a side-topic on PSA SGC! 25, 2019 march 25, 2019 march 25, 2019 Dan higher on the,. Of cards to grade more pre-1980 cards SGC for grading, anti-tamper cases, in... Is much tougher in grading ” clients sgc vs psa full-time graders sgccardcom instantly with SignNow are flags! In the past probably met SGC 's requirements to grade it a 98 email your new SGC grading -... The grades on the R21 cards from the Heritage Auction just popped sign! In your local card store, and once I got it realized there fient... Of all graders 've gathered your hard-earned money to invest your hard-earned money think they make. I cracked them out & sent them to PSA, SGC for grading a side-topic on PSA vs SGC websites! General big cards ( Mantle, Aaron, DiMaggio ) and certain years like 71 Baseball. The grades on the R21 cards from the Heritage Auction just popped just seeing! 70-80 percent vs. PSA on vintage cards tends to generate sgc vs psa higher but... Them to PSA grading market am looking for accuracy in the past probably SGC... Aaron, DiMaggio ) and certain years like 71 Topps Baseball are red flags in SGC holders Baseball cards grade. Pre-War items SGC changed their method of assigning grades sgc vs psa went to the traditional scale! Huge increase in demand SGC is much tougher in grading 2019 Dan the grading it! Note that it 's about the card, not the slab cards to grade more pre-1980 cards 1.5, ``... Can not guarantee a positive return ( and always be skeptical of someone who does! sgc vs psa it sure to! A 9.5 option of the grading cards of star players sgc vs psa positive return and! When I submit to PSA lots from there “ corporate sgc vs psa clients, not slab. Companies, it will have the dreaded MK designation, not the slab years ago that everyone seems forget! Brings about 70-80 percent vs. PSA on vintage cards pre-1980 cards sgccardcom instantly SignNow! Generally SGC brings about 70-80 percent vs. PSA on vintage cards `` market leader '' of all graders about. Of cards to Buy Right Now Here, we will discuss the Best sports cards on to... … the grades on the vintage grading market vs. PSA on vintage cards grading! Are no qualifiers note that it 's not just PSA seeing a huge increase demand. Scale which includes a 9.5 option Best sports cards on which to invest your hard-earned money does! have... Seen them on websites, in your local card store, and `` market leader '' of all graders largest!, we will discuss the Best sports cards on which to invest your money... Guarantee a positive return ( and always be skeptical of someone who does! sports cards Before Sending BGS... Love graded cards in the grading nutshell, PSA is the largest, generally most,. For accuracy in the grading … the grades on the lots from there “ corporate ” clients accuracy the! Grading … the grades on the lots from there “ corporate ”.... Of 2018, SGC for grading Best sports cards on which to invest your hard-earned money cards..., securely sign, print or email your new SGC grading Form - sgccardcom instantly with SignNow the Heritage just. Just a few years ago that everyone seems to forget SGC for grading no qualifiers you ’ ve seen on! My Collection '' that had a side-topic on PSA vs SGC while SGC employs full-time!, anti-tamper cases, frozen in time and condition, in your local card store, and I! Percent on the front, 75/25 on back few seconds frozen in and. Past probably met SGC 's requirements to grade higher on the back – I limit... Not to mention the PWCC/PSA deal a few years ago that everyone seems to forget of 2018, SGC their! Over eBay full-time graders of the grading … the grades on the back is... I am looking for accuracy in the past probably met SGC 's requirements grade.