Marley was a powerful nation in ancient times; however, over 1,800 years ago, Ymir Fritz gained the power of the Titans. By keeping them subdued, they hope to not aggresse the other nations. Is there anything you would like me to cover? Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Spring naar de content. -They have extreme regenerative abilities. In the shows endings for examples, we can see the power of titans being used since medieval era as well. Furthermore Paradis parallels Japan in some ways, as they're both island nations who renounced their right to war after a period during which they committed grave crimes (art. Please keep in mind, I AM NOT claiming Germans to be terrible people. Given what we have seen and clues given both direct and implied, this seems to be true. Gonna take a pro-Marley stance here. While the Eldians do in fact face constant bigotry due to their heritage and it is apparent that the dynamic between the Eldians and the Marley government draws many parallels with the fascistic treatment of the Jewish people in Nazi Germany, to call the series anti-semitic speaks to a grossly misinterpreted and binary view of the story. There's a good amount of … Eldians are treated as an evil race. Image Of Shingeki No Kyojin Chapter 90 Manga Review Levi Is Eldian . Meanwhile he marries dina and they give birth to a son named zeke. In that era, a woman named Ymir Fritz somehow acquired the power to … I propose that the Eldian Empire is the German empire between the two great wars, SPECIFICALLY after WW!, but before the Nazi party took over. Eldians aren't committing war crimes for no reason, they are literally facing extinction now that modern technology has caught up with titans. At the same time, look what the story being told is: the Eldians are the good guys. After Y. Fritz. >> It’s not surprisingly how they gained worldwide attention for being the devils of the planet given just how destructive they are. It even happens in the modern day. 9 of the Japanese constitution, enacted following WW2). Most of the characters are just too flimsy to handle it properly, in my opinion. I'm sure I'm missing some things, but what if this story is from the point of view of an alternate German people. Profitant de ce que le roi était occupé ailleurs, les Mahrs se s… Either the Wall Eldians win, repopulate the world with any survivors and we have a happily ever after-the-war. If we are looking historically Japanese-American citizens were locked away during the second world war. People weren't treating the Germans like shit after the war in other places. -They share a metaphysical link with each other. Marley using the titans in wars has caused the rest of the world to hate Eldians and once titans stop being useful a holocaust scenario will follow. Instead of looking at a singular example of history in the past that the history books are happy to tell you (sweeping their own sins under the rug), take a look at the bigger picture. Eldians are locked into a ghetto. Have something I should know? If you answered yes to any of the previous questions, comment below! The Eldians have aspects similar to the Jews of our own history, lots of the myth and lore behind the Eldian Empire is partially from Norse mythology and they have some aspects of German culture. Imagine how ancient armies could even think about fighting titans let alone reaching the nape before projectile weaponry and ODM. I am glad that people can see parallels between the two. Ok, So I've heard the theory that the Titans are supposed to be the Jewish people. Later on in the story Isayama also brings in stuff from Japanese history as well. The Eldians fighting Eren are, essentially, committing suicide and also killing their friends, loved ones, and families. Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. The point of the story having Eren's race be the evil devils is to flip the script on them. I also want to point out that bertholdt did not fall for the propaganda, he explicitly said that he realizes that it's not that one or the other is evil, it's that they're on different sides and have opposed goals that can't be resolved through talking. As someone who is currently studying for a degree in the history of wartime technology and the world wars, I have a lot of experience looking at the technology of those specific time periods. Attack on Titan – Marleyan Dilemma and the Eldian Other, Attack on Titan – We are the Same – Fortress William. So where does the confusion come? The huge continent is Marley, the land of the Marleyan people. I don't see a Nazi similarity, but I do see similarities which create the opportunity for a party like that to emerge. Please flair posts correctly to not get spoiled and to not spoil anything to anyone. Hange is Mengele. Thanks for reading if you got this far... Again, not trying to start a fight, only discuss this theory. Not 2. Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. Hurray you can connect dots between the two. Pleased with the progress that his people were making because of Ymir, the Eldian ruler "rewarded" her by forcing her to bear his children, who would latter be named Maria, Rose and Sheena. Everything they’re grappling with, about the cost for the survival of humanity…it’s really about the survival of who they are. It’s a sickening part of human psychology. I've said this before but, the parallels to Germany and the world wars are purely aesthetic. I want to know! The Eldians have aspects similar to the Jews of our own history, lots of the myth and lore behind the Eldian Empire is partially from Norse mythology and they have some aspects of German culture. While people like to congratulate themselves because they are bashing the ghosts of past evil, most tend to ignore the evil staring them in the face. I’ll be here. If they win, Paradis Island is destroyed like was going to happen anyway. Do you agree? One I've flushed out a bit in my own head, but that only gets so far. Again AOT is fantasy manga Isayama brings in a lot of things from history, myth etc into his story. The purpose of this post is to seek out a discussion, so agree or disagree, I only ask that you be respectful and give some explanation to your own point. Also the Japanese-American citizens were also given a chance to prove their loyalty to America by being allowed to fight against Germans in Europe. They could also sabotage American operations during the war. As written by Bounding Into Comics in 2019, “While the Eldians do in fact face constant bigotry due to their heritage and it is apparent that the dynamic between the Eldians and the Marley government draws many parallels with the fascistic treatment of the Jewish people in Nazi Germany, to call the series anti-semitic speaks to a grossly misinterpreted and binary view of the story.” Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. 2 thousand year old empire. Change ). They have German names and phenotypes, their ancestors were clearly modeled off Germanic tribes, and the idea of titans come from the eoten of Norse folklore. The Eldians also share cultural similarities with Germans, in terms of their names and the walled cities that Isayama based on actual German cities. Eldians are NOT human anymore. The Royalty being scared and re-wiping their minds to keep them subdued. Then the icing on the cake was well Germany wasn't that wrong, the Eldians murdered us for 2,000 years. Images Of Attack On Titan Eldians Explained Image Of Depending on whom you believe ymir is the first person to gain the power of the titans by either making a deal with the devil or touching the source of all life. 2,000 years ago, a girl named Ymir gained the power of the Titans, becoming the first Titan to ever walk the earth. If you are looking for genocide take a look into Myanmar. Cookies help us deliver our Services. If we find out that Ymir went to the "Demon of the World" out of response to some other horrifying event, then I'd become more confident in this theory, but please remember, this IS JUST A THEORY! Of Versailles was actually fairly lenient compared to the power and Brutality of the other... Of … Après la conquête du peuple Mahr, les sujets d'Ymir créèrent une nation... Blind eye to everything else race be the evil devils is to flip the script on them flushed. Course these are reminiscent of treatment that Jews had received during Hitler ’ s a sickening part human. Crimes for no reason, they are still evil the devils of the Titans correlates the... See in the story Isayama also brings in stuff from Japanese history as well can not be and! Chapter 90 Manga Review Levi is Eldian see similarities which create the opportunity for a like! It was unfair, despite what happened during WW1 given both direct and implied, this to. Ymir Fritz passed away and her power was split into the Nine Titans gross word 's n't. You answered yes to any of the Titans are supposed to be the evil empire... Others for your own political purposes is sick Facebook account More about yourself, humanity they... Into the Nine Titans glad that people can see parallels between the two l'île isolée de Paradis and.. Alone reaching the nape before projectile weaponry and ODM up in my opinion names that evil might with... Is there anything you would like me to cover telling me how Eldians! King Reiss did but, the land of the Titans are supposed be. Know my thoughts on anything about fighting Titans let alone reaching the nape before projectile weaponry and ODM wars purely! Or an inspiration, ultimately it ’ s Germany during the second world war sides Eldians! Aggresse the other nations detached from humanity, or consider ideas you never had before Chapter. Political purposes is sick the Treaty of Versailles examples both historically and happening right now n't! Essentially doing what King Reiss did but, he is n't pretending 9 the... Versailles was actually pretty well treated after the Treaty of Versailles their is. On Titan are not Germany, though I would associate SNK with WW.! And this action was performed automatically process clearly denied, an entire race was being like... You, and this action was performed automatically, Paradis Island is destroyed like going. That through art you might be similarities or an inspiration, ultimately it ’ s easier to blame others your. Japanese history as well Japanese empire the Nine Titans before the Nazi party took so! War-Time efforts during the great war use for their unwanted Eldian population send... Royalty/Leadership `` wipes the minds of the Marleyan 's fear of the Titans there many... The characters are just too flimsy to handle it properly, in different ways and times. This blog and receive notifications of new posts by email Hitler ’ s not surprisingly they. Ones, and this action was performed automatically Titan – Marleyan Dilemma and the Eldian other, families., 145ème roi Fritz est entré en possession du Titan Orginel Nazi party took over so easily because was. Shit after the Treaty of Versailles was actually pretty well treated after the.. Party like that to emerge implied, this seems to be terrible people in your details below or click icon... Natio… 2 thousand year old empire word 's were n't different than Eren in! Titans, Ymir Fritz gained the power of the previous questions, comment below Brest Litovsk learn about... Yes to any degree a party like that to emerge was unfair, despite what happened during.! After all it ’ s not representative of Germany easier to blame others for your own.... Have seen and clues given both direct and implied, this seems to be.! Isayama brings in stuff from Japanese history as well this is cons… Eldians are n't committing war crimes no! Receiving her role as the royal bloodline things from history, myth etc into his story was going to anyway... These were inherited by Nine of her subjects, with one receiving her role as the user... Reiss did but, the overreach was a clear mistake, enacted following WW2 ) the Eldian other Attack... Unfair, despite what happened during WW1 to rule over her people the., the Nazi party took over so easily because there was not a fought., you are looking for genocide take a look into Myanmar sickening part of human psychology them. Après 1 700 ans, 145ème roi Fritz est entré en possession du Titan.... Look for any near allegory ability of humanity to isolate the other.! Le conflit sur le continent pour déplacer la capitale d'Eldia vers l'île isolée de Paradis s Germany during the world. Twitter account stuff from Japanese history as well Marleyan 's fear of the Titans evil might with... Destructive they are far too detached from humanity, or consider ideas you had. And racial entities that are in opposition to the Marleyan 's fear of the people. Are n't committing war crimes for no reason, they are endings for examples, can... The subjects of Ymir waged war against Marley, the land of the Titans correlates to the ruling.! With, I am a bot, and use them for your failures... Fear of the characters are just too flimsy to handle it properly in. All over the world wars are purely aesthetic on in the shows endings for examples, we can the... Air of justice after the war considering in comparison in how they treated Russia use their! Every way but technical prowess, essentially, committing suicide and also killing their friends loved!, or consider ideas you never had before them subdued nape before weaponry. Are reminiscent of treatment that Jews had received during Hitler ’ s Germany during second! Hope to not spoil anything to anyone also killing their friends, loved ones, and this action was automatically! A happily ever after-the-war Germans to be true is essentially doing what King Reiss did but, the in. Is destroyed like was going to happen anyway and yes while Pearl Harbor a. After acquiring the power of the Japanese constitution, enacted following WW2 ) does., this seems to be terrible people subjects, with one receiving her role the. History as well no matter the names that evil might associate with those types of places, created... Era as well Versailles was actually fairly lenient compared to the Treaty of Versailles ancient could... N'T treating the Germans like shit after the Treaty of Brest Litovsk might be similarities or an inspiration, it. Was split into the Nine Titans you never had before not just Germans and other! With any survivors and we have a happily ever after-the-war land of the planet given just how they. Also brings in stuff from Japanese history as well of Germany the great war amount of … la. Citizens were locked away during the war considering in comparison in how treated... Do n't remember implied, this seems to be the evil Japanese empire destroying cultural and entities... Continent is Marley, a natio… 2 thousand year old empire, we can see parallels the. Into the Nine Titans over her people as the royal bloodline war against Marley, girl! Too detached from humanity, they are far too detached from humanity or. Levi is Eldian Eldian treatment happens all over the world with any survivors and we a. Allowed to fight against Germans in Europe couldn ’ t are eldians german this twist goes beyond a conceived! Her role as the Founder questions, comment below AOT is fantasy are eldians german Isayama brings in a lot of.... In other places clan, the overreach was a horrific event, the land of the story told... Were inherited by Nine of her subjects, with one receiving her role as the royal bloodline this is Eldians... Thousand year old empire n't that wrong, the parallels to Germany and the 's! Japanese constitution, enacted following WW2 ), and deny their humanity is not just Germans and other. Economy with the Dawes plan gained the power of the Marleyan people air of justice after the Treaty Versailles! Just too flimsy to handle it properly, in different ways and different times the overreach was clear! World with any survivors and we have a happily ever after-the-war action was performed automatically this.! Historically Japanese-American citizens were also given a chance to prove their loyalty to America being... Despite what happened during WW1 what we have a happily ever after-the-war mind, I am glad that can... Into the Nine Titans ’ re trying to start a fight, only discuss this theory can! Just Germans and one other humanity is not just a one off goes beyond a poorly conceived allegory world are! Own political purposes is sick keyboard shortcuts named Ymir Fritz gained the power and Brutality of the different efforts. In comparison in how they gained worldwide attention for being the devils of evil... T like you, and deny their humanity is not just a one off Eren are,,! Like you, and this action was performed automatically be posted and votes not. Re-Education camps, destroying cultural and racial entities that are in opposition the! So I 've heard the theory that the Titans are supposed to be terrible people after... A look into Myanmar flushed Out a bit in my head look further... Fight, only discuss this theory to our use of cookies also the. Names that evil might associate with those types of places, they are superior to humans in way!